I have been researching two-stage testing for several years and finally had the opportunity to introduce it to one of the courses I teach this semester: MATH 2720 (Multivariable Calculus). We had our first test last Friday, and it went really well!
For those unfamiliar with two-stage testing, here’s a definition from SALTISE: Two-Stage Exam. A two-stage assessment is an instructional strategy where students complete an assessment (exam, test, or quiz) in two stages. First, they work individually and submit their answers. Then, in the second stage, they collaborate in groups to answer either the most challenging questions from the individual portion or new, more conceptual or open-ended questions.
While working on the course syllabus in June, I chatted with two colleagues whose work I admire regarding the logistics of two-stage testing. We discussed how to allocate time for each stage, how to organize the second stage (group) materials efficiently, and how to distribute the grade weighting between the stages. Ultimately, I decided to conduct the individual test during the Friday lecture and the group test during lab time later that afternoon, with a couple of hours between the two stages. During that gap, students were allowed to discuss the test with their peers but could not post any questions online. The second-stage test featured similar questions, allowing students to know what to expect. I used this tool to randomly assign students into groups of four.
The main reason I introduced this testing format is that one of the course’s goals is to develop students’ ability to work collaboratively to solve problems. During the design stage of the course, I ensured there were ample opportunities for students to work together during lectures and labs. I wanted this emphasis on collaboration to be reflected in their assessments as well. This semester, there are four tests, each focusing on a key topic: multivariable functions, derivatives and their applications, integrals and applications, and vector calculus.
After the test, I asked students for feedback since this was a new experience for all of them. The response was overwhelmingly positive. Many appreciated the chance to work with their peers and correct mistakes they made during the individual stage. The format seems to genuinely support their learning. I am really glad to observe so many happy faces when they were writing their group test: when was the last time you see a student being so happy taking a math exam?!
I wish I had a longer lab assigned for this course because I had to sacrifice lecture time (50 min*4) to run the first stage. This means during those weeks there is a risk of me not being able to cover all the content that was planned for that week. I decided to make supplementary videos so students can watch at home if we can’t finish that week’s materials by the end of Wednesday class. When I asked students whether there is anything they’d like me to do differently in the third week, many of them wanted me to cover more examples in class, and more than half want me to go slower. Apparently I can’t do both at the same time because my lecture time is fixed. So posting videos of me going over examples is the perfect solution to address both concerns.
If you’re interested in learning more about the course structure, you can find the syllabus here: MATH 2720 Syllabus.
If you are interested in having a chat with me about two-stage testing, please reach out to me via email: I’d love to hear your thoughts.