I have been researching two-stage testing for several years and finally had the opportunity to introduce it to one of the courses I teach this semester: MATH 2720 (Multivariable Calculus). We had our first test last Friday, and it went really well!
For those unfamiliar with two-stage testing, here’s a definition from SALTISE: Two-Stage Exam. A two-stage assessment is an instructional strategy where students complete an assessment (exam, test, or quiz) in two stages. First, they work individually and submit their answers. Then, in the second stage, they collaborate in groups to answer either the most challenging questions from the individual portion or new, more conceptual or open-ended questions.
The whole teaching and learning community has been talking about assessments among other things: should quizzes/tests/final exams still exist? What about third-party proctoring services? Personally I do not think using proctoring service and watching students via a camera is the solution. It comes with very high cost, and there are serious ethical issues that come with this practice. Can we redesign course assessments so that we can give the trust back to students?
I believe the answer is yes, and a few simple things instructors can do is to first take a close look at your syllabus and ask yourself why the assessments are there at the first place. Most of the time the goal is to actually help students consolidate what they have learned, and a by-product is a number, i.e. grade. If that’s the case, shifting to summative assessments is one way to help with the current situation. We can also provide assessments more frequently so students can receive more timely feedback.
I’ve been experimenting with H5P since last year when I started working on the open textbook. These are excellent tools that instructors can leverage on to engage students and monitor their progress in a nonstressful manner.
Below is a recent example I made using course presentation format. These interactive presentation slides allow instructors to incorporate course content, assessment, and students reflection all at one place.